jump to navigation

Revealing? Arch-liberal Blase Cupich to keynote 2016 Dallas Ministry Conference April 13, 2016

Posted by Tantumblogo in catachesis, Dallas Diocese, disaster, episcopate, error, foolishness, General Catholic, Revolution, scandals, secularism, self-serving, Society, the struggle for the Church.

There are a lot of local wags and cultural observers who have noted for decades that there are many influential elements in Dallas who would really, really like to see this city be another Los Angeles.  I think Cactus Pryor and Becky Patterson Crouch both noted this, and I’ve heard it many other places besides.

In that spirit, perhaps, it’s not terribly surprising that several years ago the Diocese of Dallas started a “ministry conference” that  emulated the infamous religious education conferences sponsored by the Archdiocese of Los Angeles every year.  Heretofore, this conference had been run formally in conjunction with the still somewhat orthodox University of Dallas and also in conjunction with the Diocese of Fort Worth, but this year the conference was renamed just the Dallas Ministry Conference (instead of the UD ministry conference), and perhaps more significantly, the Diocese of Fort Worth also terminated their association with this annual event.  Of the two separations, the latter is probably more telling.

Folks I know in the Diocese of Fort Worth, who would be well placed to know, have long had problems with the Dallas Ministry Conference. Every year, apparently, it was something of a fight to get good speakers/lecturers brought in, and keep bad ones out.  As an example, the very problematic – I would say heretical – Fr. Ron Rolheiser spoke at the conference in 2011.  And this year, the arch-liberal Archbishop Blase Cupich has been brought in to give the keynote speech.  I’m not certain whether it was the Cupich invite, or just general frustration (again, as I have been told) that caused Fort Worth to back out of their monetary support for the conference, but I doubt it helped.  It’s a bit telling, perhaps, that Fort Worth Bishop Michael Olson, who was previously rector of the Dallas seminary, would make this decision, however.  One can imagine the tenor of the discussion which may have preceded this decision.

Another factor concerning the Dallas Ministry Conference is that it has become very much an insider event.  The large minority, if not clear majority, of attendees are either employed as teachers/catechists at regional parishes, or individuals who have significant volunteer roles involving same.  That is to say, this is essentially a glitzy teacher’s conference for the schools of the Diocese of Dallas.  That’s being a bit reductive, but is another complaint regarding the conference from diocesan insiders themselves.  Many people attend simply because their parish, under diocesan impetus, buys a block of tickets, and then hands the tickets out to teachers and catechists. They get in free, and are supposedly receiving solid formation at diocesan expense.  While the quality of speakers varies wildly, one thing is certain: the orthodox Faith of the Ages is rarely taught in its completeness or with the clarity and force it both deserves and requires.  This is a conference mired in the post-conciliar ethos, with all that entails, little of it, from my perspective, good.  Thus, the big grey machine just keeps stammering along, its motion propelled less by its own energy but more by the momentum it inherited from the “bad old Church.”  Events like this are inherently problematic from my point of view, being, by their nature, “of the bureaucracy, by the bureaucracy, and for the bureaucracy.”

I don’t think I need to go on at length regarding the myriad problems of inviting a man like Blase Cupich to keynote a conference on religious education.  He is the darling of the most progressive, I would even say left-wing, elements in the Church.  He has already given scandal on numerous occasions, belittling if not directly contradicting Church Doctrine on subjects ranging from the sanctity of the Blessed Sacrament to the sanctity of marriage.  His presence gravely undermines whatever good more orthodox conference speakers – almost entirely lay people whose moral authority is thus greatly limited – manage to communicate.  I don’t know if there will be any pre-review or approval of his intended speech text, but I think it poses a threat to communicate beliefs potentially hazardous to many if not all listeners.  Faith comes by hearing (Rom x:17), but so does error and beliefs tending towards loss of faith.  I fear what this speech portends, since it seems part of a series of decisions by Bishop Farrell of late that indicate a turn towards the progressive.

It seems an eon ago since Bishop Farrell, in conjunction with then Bishop Kevin Vann, issued their strong pastoral document in the run-up to the 2008 election making it clear that Catholics could never,  under any circumstances, vote for a pro-abort politician.  Now, instead of that, we get massive overreactions to legitimate firearms legislation and blanket bans on firearms possession in diocesan facilities.  Interesting, as they say. Revealing? I think so.  Bishop Farrell has long had the reputation of being very attuned to internal Church politics and he can easily see which way the wind is blowing.

And so can Bishop Olson.  Just sayin’.

On a personal note, starting a new job has of course been a very busy time.  Things are starting to settle just a bit, so I hope to do a post or two every day or so at least for a while.  Some days there will be none.  It won’t be like it was for the foreseeable future. I’ll do what I can.  Thank you for your patience.


1. tg - April 13, 2016

Hope all goes well with your new job.

2. Baseballmom - April 13, 2016

Thank YOU for continuing…. Of course the job comes first…. And at home, the family… Praying all goes well in the new position. 😀

3. Warren Memlib - April 13, 2016

As the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress has become know as the “LA-REC”, will the Dallas Ministry Conference become know as the “D-Min Conference”?

4. Dennis Hogan - April 14, 2016

The disenchantment with the Ministry Conference had been building to a crescendo in Ft. Worth long before Olson came along as bishop.
Ft. Worth participants had been complaining about the rising admission costs, the doubtful benefits of the meeting, and the “poor cousin” attitude toward Ft. Worth in the planning, choice of speakers, and selection of the conference site.
It was practically a no-brainer to cancel Ft. Worth’s participation.

5. Anne Marie - April 14, 2016

As I recall, Cardinal Mahoney was invited a few years ago to give the keynote address at the Dallas Ministry Conference. Last year, I was thinking of attending a few of the seminars on education, but when I looked up the backgrounds of the speakers, I was stunned to see that most were proponents of the Common Core (or whatever their latest pseudonym is). Not much offered on either homeschooling or Theology of the Body. Certainly a lost opportunity to help inform folks about the faith and its many practical applications in all aspects of our lives. I agree with you that there’s an agenda in play. Btw, congrats on your new job! I’m happy that your prayers were answered, but I sure do miss your daily blog….try to write when you have a chance. Blessings to you & the family.

6. camper - April 14, 2016

Somebody should demonstrate at the Ministry Conference, calling Cupich a heretic.

7. Maggie - April 14, 2016

I am so sorry for the faithful in the Dallas archdiocese who are pummeled with all this. But perhaps going in this –could we say “Francis direction” may be something some clerics might seek for some reasons of their own?

8. David - April 17, 2016

I have never been to the Dallas Ministry Conference, and one year in particular I did not attend because Mahony was invited.

However, I am a CCD substitute teacher ( I have been a regular teacher) and the DRE made it Optional (not mandatory) for us to attend. I hope some other parishes did the same.

Tantumblogo - April 18, 2016

I think it varies by parish, but folks are generally encouraged to attend, with varying amounts of emphasis.

9. David - April 17, 2016

Kudos to the Fort Worth Diocese for putting there foot down. In 2008, a Fullness of Truth, which I attended, was held at the Arlington Convention Center. Then-Bishop Vann supported it, and many Fort Worth area parishes advertised it. I still remember Fr. Hart doing Sunday Mass and highlighting in his homily why he left the Episcopal Church.

Going back to circa 2003, a Fullness of Truth was held in Plano, and to my knowledge, since I did attend, very few parishes even knew it was happening, and I think it was ignored at a higher level. A missed opportunity.

10. reader - April 20, 2016

In the secular news lately.

Teaching consultant: Being on time, giving grades are forms of ‘white supremacy’



minorities say cultural diversity is definition of academic rigor —
“Racially diverse ‘new majority’ set to reshape US public schools”


Sorry comments are closed for this entry

%d bloggers like this: